Jonathan - 2-2-2007 at 06:58 PM
What would be the disadvantage of having the braces flare out a bit as they approach the bowl? That is, making the braces as one would typically,
but, at the ends (say for about 1/2 of an inch), have them flare out a bit so that there is more surface area in contact with the bowl (rather than,
for example, a 1/4 inch contact, have a 3/4 inch contact)?
Dr. Oud - 2-3-2007 at 01:25 PM
I think it would change the charateristics of the brace in unforseen ways. My guess is that the face would not be as responsive and the oud would
sound more like a guitar, which has more robust brace connection with the sides. I have noticed a difference in even adding small corner blocks in
between the braces for added support. It's the very delicate nature of the oud's construction that seems to give it that special tone that we are all
seeking. It's my opinion that any increase in the size of a critical component like a brace would certainly affect the sound.
oudmaker - 2-13-2007 at 12:49 PM
I agree
jdowning - 2-14-2007 at 03:16 PM
I agree with Richard. No harm in experimenting - if you have the time and resources - but the essential geometry and construction of most successful
instruments - those physical and acoustical characteristics that make an oud an oud, a lute a lute, a violin a violin etc etc, have already been
worked out and tested by countless makers over the centuries. Best to follow the traditions of the past masters in my opinion.