Mike's Oud Forums
Not logged in [Login - Register]
Go To Bottom

Printable Version  
 Pages:  1  2
Author: Subject: Another Carbon Fiber Oud
Dr. Oud
Oud Junkie
*****




Posts: 1370
Registered: 12-18-2002
Location: Sacramento, CA, USA
Member Is Offline

Mood: better than before

[*] posted on 12-30-2012 at 09:54 AM


Quote: Originally posted by baseelo  
Wonderful job Philip!!

I think that the best invention that any oud maker could come up with is a pegbox/pegs that minimizes the possibility of the srtings going out of tune. This is an issue that is important to any oudy. So please put it on your future agenda of things to do!!

The problem is not the pegbox or pegs, (unless you have poorly fitted pegs). The strings, the wood face and the body all expand and contract even with small changes in temperature and humidity, so there is no solution to the problem of tuning. Otherwise it would have been solved for other stringed instruments long ago, ya think? The best you can do is be sure your pegs are properly fitted so they don't slip, and keep your oud in a climate controlled room and never take it out, 'cause it will surely change pitch.




View user's profile Visit user's homepage View All Posts By User
Philip Shaheen
Oud Admirer
*




Posts: 2
Registered: 12-31-2012
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 1-2-2013 at 12:16 PM
my first post


I have no doubt that Dr. Oud and many more people have thought about building a carbon fiber oud. It is expected from scientific and industrial aspects that it was only a matter of time till this happens. Bringing an idea to this level with such product is totally a different story.

I'm a die and mold engineer, cutting tools designer, a process innovator, craftsman and oud player, and above all an open-minded person who appreciate the expertise of other people and get to learn from them. Hard work and patience is paid off at the end.

Wood of course, is "anisotropic" material (means that mechanical properties varies with the wood grain direction), but it is possible to simulate the behavior of wood when you have the right knowledge, reference academic researches made on wood, scientific tools and the proper "pilot" behind the wheel.
Moreover, what you have seen at the movie was the 4th vibration mode out of 6 vibration modes that me and my friend (PhD expert in sound and vibration analysis) have done to compare the effect of different bracing pattern on the natural frequencies for two different sound boards, we kept the same wood properties but changed the geometry (one must agree that this is possible) by the way !! We've considered the orientation of the wood grain for the bracing too.

The contribution of the body to the sound ? A much more talented man than my self "Antonio de Torres Jurado" the famous guitar maker has said "back and sides contribute very little to the sound quality"… assuming that the oud body have a major roll for the sound quality, what do you think would happen with the oud sound when you hold it close to your body… I think it will be blocked by the human body.
I thought it will be most appropriate to adapt this concept for my oud…. It is fine with me if you choose to use a different technique.

Baseelo point of view: I believe this was a good hunch, when the wood is sensitive to weather condition, while carbon Fiber is not. When you deal with 100% wood oud you usually get 100% response to climate. With 60% carbon in the oud you only have to worry about 40% of the problem.
Pegs/pegs house, the angle and stiffness of the peg house are also very sensitive to tuning control.

I'm not a scientist, just an oud lover who is motivated by a charisma for innovation, a smile and thrill of other oud passionates when they meet this oud. I'm expecting an objective criticism that promotes to improve the product.

I refuse to accept any credit that is not mine, but maybe I've succeeded to convince more forum members that this achievement deserves respect.
I truly believe that any support of the experienced forum members will contribute to bring this product even for higher levels.

Wish you all the best
Philip Shaheen
View user's profile View All Posts By User
fernandraynaud
Oud Junkie
*****




Posts: 1865
Registered: 7-25-2009
Location: San Francisco, California
Member Is Offline

Mood: m'Oudy

[*] posted on 1-2-2013 at 03:04 PM


The concept that the back and sides of string instruments play no role in the timbre does not agree with experience, or current luthier thinking. Tightly hugging my ouds sure changes the sound. Carbon may be usable, but it will somewhat affect the timbre, for better or worse, just as Ovation guitars have a specific sound. It's not clear that it would solve the tuning issues.

The problem of tuning stability has been even more daunting when many more strings are involved, and has been attacked for centuries. The modern piano has overcome it with an all iron frame, not too practical for an oud. But short of that, even instruments made of synthetics exhibit shifts, because even minimally humidity/temp reactive materials stretch. The changes can then be magnified or reduced by specific geometries.

Many harpsichords have been built with different materials to improve tuning stability, with poor results. Only John Challis' all-aluminum design has worked well. On the oud it's doubtful that what is, on a good instrument, a minor tuning drift, would disappear just by using a synthetic bowl. The strings alone play a significant role.

And it's an interesting fact that long style clavichords, made entirely of wood, are generally very stable, while other instruments in the same room go desperately out of tune.

http://www.hpschd.nu/index.html?nav/nav-4.html&t/welcome.html&a...

It is believed that it's due to the way different wooden members in the design work against each other, creating a self-compensating geometry. I have a Zuckermann like that.

I bring that up because it suggests that, perhaps by adding some cross-members, or specific bracing, an oud could be made much more stable than usual, without using metal or synthetics. It's a design more than just a materials issue, I think. Some existing (all wood) ouds are more stable than others.

As to the all-carbon fiber oud, if the whole bowl/neck/pegbox is all one piece, I suppose it might be rigid enough to help. But in practice (with the other parts and strings) does it really hold tuning perfectly?

Such an oud could probably be mass-produced, and there's room for different approaches, though people are attracted to wood. Not just ouds. Electric guitars could be made of anything, yet most players always come back to wood. No offense intended, your carbon ouds can be wonderful on their own merits.
View user's profile View All Posts By User
SamirCanada
Moderator
******




Posts: 3405
Registered: 6-4-2004
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 1-3-2013 at 05:17 AM


A question for Philip,

When playing the carbon ouds you have made, do you feel it in your gut? I ask this because when playing a good wooden oud, often you can feel the vibrations coming from the bowl into your belly.

to me, this is the indication that the back of the oud plays a part in the sound however minute. Perhaps by absorbing vibrations or not absorbing them as much depending on the species of wood or now depending on the material wood vs carbon.

From the videos you posted, it seems like the oud projects very loudly. much louder than a traditional oud. The ouds do sound new so it will be interesting to see how the carbon oud sounds with a top that has been aged a few years. I find from experience after a oud reaches 7-10 years you can really start to hear a difference in the sound.

As for tuning, mechanical violin "peg heads" and other devises have been invented to hold the tuning. My opinino is that its fair to say the problem lies just as much with the strings which constanly strech no mater what. There might be a point when you feel they are being relatively stable (in a stable atmospheric enviorment also) but you just may no longer notice they are streching however they surely they are constantly streching as long as tension is applied to them. Perhaps different string material would solve this issue but not without changing the tone of the oud we have come to apreciate.




@samiroud Instagram
samiroudmaker@gmail.com
View user's profile View All Posts By User
Philip Shaheen
Oud Admirer
*




Posts: 2
Registered: 12-31-2012
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 1-4-2013 at 08:28 PM


Answer to Samir

"When playing the carbon ouds you have made, do you feel it in your gut? " – NO

Actually it was the first remark I had from an oud player a friend of mine, he said "I feel that the sound is moving away from me, could not feel it in my body".

I also didn't notice it my self, even when I tried a lot of times with 4 ouds I have for the past two days. I think this feeling is individual, maybe it can be measured, let me think about it….
View user's profile View All Posts By User
hussamd
Oud Junkie
*****




Posts: 117
Registered: 12-18-2013
Location: Bartlett, IL
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 1-10-2014 at 05:25 AM


Any updates on this topic? I watched the clips and the oud sounded wonderful. I have mixed feelings on this topic since beauty is one integral piece of this instrument (to me at least), along with a rich voice. The fancy woodwork on some ouds is breathtaking. Personally I would rather see the nice wood grain so if I get yelled at when playing it, I can at least use it as art :D
View user's profile View All Posts By User
 Pages:  1  2

  Go To Top

Powered by XMB
XMB Forum Software © 2001-2011 The XMB Group