fernandraynaud
Oud Junkie
Posts: 1865
Registered: 7-25-2009
Location: San Francisco, California
Member Is Offline
Mood: m'Oudy
|
|
How do you fine-tune your oud ?
I haven't been able to find this topic, forgive me if it's been handled before. Are people tuning the oud's strings to perfect 5ths (by listening to
beats and harmonics, tricky with dual strings), or using a tuner, or a piano, or what?
If you work up in perfect 5ths, you won't land on a perfect octave. If you use equal temperament, like from a tuner, you get perfect octaves but your
open strings are a bit out of tune. How do people approach this complex subject?
For harpsichord there are several very different "temperaments" in use, Equal Temperament being considered unacceptably boring, as the best ones give
each scale a different "mood". It's not true that J.S. Bach invented Equal Temperament, it's been around forever, and was rejected until the piano
ruined everything. Of course on a fretless instrument, we're thankfully only talking about the open strings. What is the oud tradition? What do people
do in practice to tune?
And how perfectly in unison are courses tuned? Again, here, on Baroque instruments like the clavichord there's a tradition, and a hair off unison is
considered more beautiful.
Thanks
|
|
|
Sazi
Oud Junkie
Posts: 786
Registered: 9-17-2007
Location: Behind my oud
Member Is Offline
Mood: مبتهج ; ))
|
|
Hi Fernand, I have seen a few oud players (born into the culture) who simply tuned all the open courses by ear. Which I found to be very quick and a
good way of training the ear. If I have to be in tune with other players, I like to get a tuning fork with, for my Fcdgcf tuning, a C and tune the C
courses to that, I then tune all the other courses by ear to perfect intervals, so that all the open courses are in perfect 4ths, as it is critical
that the open courses are perfect, all other notes being "tempered" by virtue of finger position.
Then again I have also noted players tuning the open strings to the actual pitches of the notes in the particular maqam being used, (an open E being
tuned to E "1/4 tone" for instance when playing in Bayati, or other maqamat which depend on such intervals.) Though this seems to be more common among
old-school players & on older recordings.
Regarding the perfect unison question, that I think is a matter of personal perception of the sound. I have heard comments on the "too perfect" tuning
of strings such as the Nylguts from Aquila, which are all made to exacting tolerances, it seems that the minor imperfections of the strings make for a
subtly more "exciting" sound for the human ear/mind, a psycho-acoustic phenomenon.
Cheers, S
|
|
|
Luttgutt
Oud Junkie
Posts: 578
Registered: 1-10-2009
Location: Norway
Member Is Offline
Mood: Curious
|
|
This is a very difficult subject : )
For me, this depends on severel factors:
1- what kind of tuning you use (I have used GAdgc for 25 years. But 6 years ago changed to EADgcf).
2- the music you are playing.
3- What other instruments you are playing with.
1- I find the EADgcf tuning much easier, espesially when playing with tempared instruments. While with the Gg tuning, the problem you mention is
bigger.
2- Playing the frenshise style from the mid 19 century, you would have to tune the oud different from playing Om kolthum, for example! playing the
traditional old school, I would retune for each song!! Often it is the g and c strings that have to be redone.
3- playing with a piano, the EADgcf is easy. Playing with sax, you'll probable have to tune your c a litle lower.. and so on.
p.s.
If you know what style you want to play, you can find an oud player (CD) who found a good compromise (Anouar Brahem is excellent to tune to, if you
are playing with western instrument, for instance).
p.s. using tuners (all sorts) doesn't work for the oud (not for me at least).
About your other question:
Long time ago, when playing the "old school" style, I used to tune the upper string a little HIGHER then the lower one (not just a hair off, but
TWO!). When the tuning is too colse you get a horrable distortion. So there is a hair tiny interval you would want to avoid. That was never easy 
Now I don't play old school no more, and I tune the to strings perfectly together (try at least  the g string is always a pain to tune!
Hope this helps a litle.
But remember this is MY OWN experience.
Looking forward to hear from the others how they do it!
Have a nice weekend everyone
And thanks again for your support
|
|
|
fernandraynaud
Oud Junkie
Posts: 1865
Registered: 7-25-2009
Location: San Francisco, California
Member Is Offline
Mood: m'Oudy
|
|
On unisons, a perfectly perfect unison is impossible, so the phasing on almost perfect takes the volume down at times. The volume is very strong when
in phase, then suddenly weaker when out of phase, while with an offset, it's more consistent and sounds thick like a "chorus" effect.
My teacher said he tunes his g sharp for some reason he's not sure of, and that's probably that he's instinctively seeking the true 5th, not the equal
tempered one.
Sorry to bother you with harpsichord again, but there's a great demo here. After you've played a harpsichord tuned to optimize e.g. major thirds for
basic keys like C,G,D,A,F,Bb, very important in much Baroque music, playing an ET major third on a piano is horrible. But in, say, a Meantone
Temperament, the "remote" keys are not as good, the pythagorean comma gets "stuffed" into those remote keys, so if you play e.g. in C#, it sounds bad.
What the Turkish "comma" is all about is the offset between a perfect octave and an octave derived by ascending the fifths.
You can hear this very well. Brad Lehman has come up with a compromise temperament that he is convinced Bach used, that sounds gorgeous in base keys,
each key has a specific mood, but even the remote keys are acceptable. It's worth looking (and listening carefully) for the issues, he doesn't even
bother with ET, but clearly demonstrates the limitations of 1/6 Comma Meantone tuning, and a better compromise.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfK3blfKE04
I love the Lehman "Bach" temperament. For C,F,A,d,g the Lehman tuning is identical to a Vallotti, so on any versatile electronic tuner I can use the
Vallotti setting to tune my oud as well. If I tune my low strings to E and B, the E is like Vallotti and the B is about 4 cents sharp from a Vallotti.
Subtle, relevant, but those wound strings with their "steps" of course are a nightmare to tune. Flour in the windings at the nut on my next set of
strings!
I've read posts by violin players who are saying that only by tuning the open strings away from ET can they get nice sounding intervals at standard
positions. The oud player can do anything, but the trick is how to tune those open strings to work with other instruments. Let's hear what more people
are doing.
|
|
|
fernandraynaud
Oud Junkie
Posts: 1865
Registered: 7-25-2009
Location: San Francisco, California
Member Is Offline
Mood: m'Oudy
|
|
Oh, and what do people do to suppress that gorgeous sympathetic resonance while tuning? The meter will read just a tad low, I touch the peg a hair,
pluck one string and the whole enchilada answers like a choir, 10 cents high! Tricky. Use a piece of felt? Mute strings with your hand?
|
|
|
MatthewW
Oud Junkie
Posts: 1031
Registered: 11-5-2006
Location: right here
Member Is Offline
Mood: Al Salam
|
|
As mentioned, perfect unison may not be possible or even desirable...a piano tuner will tune a piano just slightly out of what we might call 'perfect
unison or perfict tuning': the reason given that if a piano was in 'perfect' tune it would sound out of tune! All the instruments in a full orchestra
anr not in total 'perfect' tuning, but the overall sound is harmony and pleasing. I think if we can train our ears to recognize if our oud is in tune
or not then that is a good way to go. For me, I use a chromatic tuner ( a Korg) to initially get tuned. After a few days or so I use my ears to see if
it sounds OK, and also use the harmonics at the neck joint to check the intonation between strings, but it's my ear that usually tells me if I am in
pitch or not.
For me ts the trick of turning the pegs just enough to get the strings in tune to eachother that I find the biggest challenge, we all know how tight
some pegs can be and that even a slight turn too much will give the wrong pitch! If a peg is too tight, I find that by tuning that particular string
down, I can then tune it back up easier to the right pitch. Someone posted a funny clip on youtube in the forum recently about some guy trying to tune
his oud using pliers on the pegs because they were so tight and squeaky!)
|
|
|
SamirCanada
Moderator
Posts: 3405
Registered: 6-4-2004
Member Is Offline
|
|
I usually tune 1 string with the help of a tuned instrument or even midi sound files.
and then I tune the other string by ear to match the previously tuned string.
When playing along with old recordings such as om kolthoum, you have to listen carefully to an open string. once you have 1 string tuned right you can
tune the rest of the instruments if you are really familiar with the intervals. I usually pick a violin open string an I tune the oud accordingly.
trust me it varies slightly between each song... I was told this is because they used to tune the Kanun according to her voice that given nite and
then the rest of the orchestra would tune to the kanun.
|
|
|
jkndrkn
Oud Addict
Posts: 37
Registered: 9-6-2009
Location: Gainesville, FL, USA
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by fernandraynaud  | | ...but those wound strings with their "steps" of course are a nightmare to tune. Flour in the windings at the nut on my next set of strings!
|
I'm experiencing similar problems with my new Sukar Model 1 and a set of Daniel Mari wound strings. I've tried placing graphite from a pencil in the
grooves of the nut, but this has not helped. It's been very difficult to get the strings in pitch due to this "catching" phenomenon.
What methods can be used to reduce this "stepping" "catching" behavior? Is it recommended to carefully shape or smooth the nut grooves using a file?
|
|
|
Alan-TX
Oud Junkie
Posts: 118
Registered: 2-18-2008
Member Is Offline
|
|
I had the same problem on my Sukar oud. I replaced the wood nut with a bone nut and now it tunes up much easier.
| Quote: Originally posted by jkndrkn |
| Quote: Originally posted by fernandraynaud | | ...but those wound strings with their "steps" of course are a nightmare to tune. Flour in the windings at the nut on my next set of strings!
|
I'm experiencing similar problems with my new Sukar Model 1 and a set of Daniel Mari wound strings. I've tried placing graphite from a pencil in the
grooves of the nut, but this has not helped. It's been very difficult to get the strings in pitch due to this "catching" phenomenon.
What methods can be used to reduce this "stepping" "catching" behavior? Is it recommended to carefully shape or smooth the nut grooves using a file?
|
|
|
|
SamirCanada
Moderator
Posts: 3405
Registered: 6-4-2004
Member Is Offline
|
|
You can also rub some graphite based pencil in the nut's slots. it will improve the glide but ultimately you want to have a nut made of bone or ebony
that has finely polished slots. the wooden one that comes on sukar ouds is junk.
|
|
|
Ararat66
Oud Junkie
Posts: 1025
Registered: 11-14-2005
Location: Portsmouth, UK
Member Is Offline
Mood: mellow yellow
|
|
What an interesting post - I can almost feel an MA (degree) brewing ... resist resist )) I'm not overly technical but could easily be, I find these
subtleties really fascinating.
You are right about tuning by ear, also the particular make up of each oud means that subtleties of tuning can really wake up the instrument. There
is also your own relationship with your oud, you yourselves are complex energetic instruments. I have found that my oud responds more and more to my
spoken voice the more I play - it reverberates and hums, and I think one becomes 'tuned' over time. Also the way the instrument reverberates in you
throat, chest belly etc - I really think that playing an instrument can tune you up.
Cheers
Leon
|
|
|
tchandler
Oud Maniac
Posts: 63
Registered: 1-10-2006
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
For what it's worth, I've always tuned by ear, but find that when I'm playing with other people, (upright bass, violin, winds etc) that the guitar
tuner can be pretty helpful.
my two cents! Get it, cents?
tom
|
|
|
jkndrkn
Oud Addict
Posts: 37
Registered: 9-6-2009
Location: Gainesville, FL, USA
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
| Quote: Originally posted by tchandler | For what it's worth, I've always tuned by ear, but find that when I'm playing with other people, (upright bass, violin, winds etc) that the guitar
tuner can be pretty helpful.
my two cents! Get it, cents?
tom
|
Yes, I'm considering purchasing one of those clip-on tuners since I can imagine that tuning up 11 strings by ear amid background chatter and noise can
be frustrating and time-consuming.
|
|
|
fernandraynaud
Oud Junkie
Posts: 1865
Registered: 7-25-2009
Location: San Francisco, California
Member Is Offline
Mood: m'Oudy
|
|
Well, no question that a bone nut is better, but from trying different ones it seems the shape of the notching is critical too, so you can make a
terrible bone nut and you can make a wood nut much better than stock. I don't yet know what the optimal grooving is, but obviously any breaks will
cause the windings to catch, so once you have an electronic tuner it's worth trying some filing, some graphite, some flour, and some prayer. Or, toss
the tuner and just play.
|
|
|
jkndrkn
Oud Addict
Posts: 37
Registered: 9-6-2009
Location: Gainesville, FL, USA
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
I'll look into getting a bone or ebony nut made if I can't successfully smooth the grooves on my wound strings.
Good advice for solo play, but I do plan on playing in non-Maqam settings with friends at some point and learning to tune up quickly and accurately is
an important priority for me :]
|
|
|
patheslip
Oud Junkie
Posts: 160
Registered: 5-24-2008
Location: Welsh Marches
Member Is Offline
Mood: smooth
|
|
In the old days mandolin bridges and nuts were sometimes made using the bones from the legs of herons. They're protected nowadays. I wonder if
anyone on the forum has tried bird bone nuts. Pheasants, pea<b>rooster</b>s, ostriches anyone?
(I've just previewed this post and found the obscenity filter has made a nonsense of the middle bird. Can anyone guess what it should be? It's a
good job I don't come from the Cumbrian place not called <b>rooster</b>ermouth. 
|
|
|
Christian1095
Oud Junkie
Posts: 454
Registered: 4-29-2008
Location: North Carolina, USA
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
Maybe it's just me, but none of my sukars are a hassle to tune (I mean, it's not like a guitar with mechanical tuners - but it's not a total pain in
the <<Donkey>> either....
Pathslip, why birds? I would think thier bones would be too light and brittle?
Chris Walters
|
|
|
![[*]](images/xmbprobrown/default_icon.gif){kind=icon}
